Return to main page of Native American Health Issues and IHS
Bill targets lack of tribal nursing homes; Measure sponsored by Daschle and
Johnson would force federal government to pay for care
September 14, 2002
By TERRY WOSTER
PIERRE - "A bill to force the federal Medicaid program to pay nursing home
costs on Indian reservations could be the answer to long-term care for
Native Americans, members of a State-Tribal Relations Committee said Friday.
The bill, sponsored by Democrat Sens. Tom Daschle and Tim Johnson, was
introduced this summer in Congress. It's far from a sure thing because the
Bush administration opposes the idea of expanding the 100 percent
federal-pay feature of Medicaid, Daschle said in a letter to the committee.
"As this provision is key in overcoming the obstacles in nursing home
funding created by the state moratorium, it will be necessary to convince
the administration to abandon its opposition,'' the letter said. "While
prospects for enacting the bill this year are uncertain, it is my hope that
its introduction will help foster a comprehensive discussion about the best
ways to provide for the long-term nursing care needs of South Dakota's
Committee members said the bill puts the responsibility for reservation
nursing homes where it belongs.
"As far as I'm concerned, the federal government has an obligation, and it
should be at 100 percent,'' said Republican Sen. Arnold Brown of Brookings.
"You can't expect the state to pick this up, and you can't expect the tribes
to pick it up. But the people do need this service. We need to twist a few
more tails to get it done adequately.''
Long-term care for the elderly on South Dakota's Indian reservations has
been a hotly debated policy issue ever since the state Legislature placed a
moratorium on new nursing home construction in 1988. The ban on new beds was
set in place for three years, then extended each time it expired.
At the time, construction of new nursing homes was outrunning the need for
space. The Department of Social Services wanted time to set in place a
screening process aimed at evaluating elderly people to decide which ones
needed the costly nursing home care and which could be served with a
less-costly alternative, such as home health services, group homes or
assisted living centers.
While state statistics continue to show a surplus of nursing home beds, no
reservation has a facility within its borders. State officials have balked
at dropping the moratorium and licensing a home on a reservation because
that would mean the state would pay a 35 percent match for Medicaid patients
at such facilities. A tribe could build and operate a nursing home without a
state license, but then it wouldn't qualify for Medicaid under current laws
Several past legislatures have killed bills to exempt reservation areas from
the nursing home moratorium. Each of the past two legislatures has adopted
resolutions to Congress, saying elderly health care on reservations is a
federal responsibility and should be included as part of Indian Health
"We've been trying to work this thing out somehow, some way, since 1989,"
said Mike Vogel, deputy secretary of Social Services.
The Daschle bill offers a solution that would help Native American elderly
without hurting either tribes or the state, he said.
"We've felt all along this would require some federal legislation," Vogel
said. "This is as far as we've ever gotten.''
Democrat Rep. Paul Valandra of Rosebud agreed.
'Promises were made'
"We believe that this is a federal responsibility, that promises were made
to Indian people by the treaties,'' he aid. "There's little or no services
provided by Indian Health Service to older Native American citizens.''
Committee members estimated that if the state were to pick up a 35 percent
share of the current need for nursing home care on reservations, it would
cost about $2.5 million. The current state budget was put together using $36
million in reserve funds to fill a revenue shortfall.
"As desperately as it's needed, there's no place in the state budget to find
that $2.5 million,'' said Republican Rep. Stan Adelstein of Rapid City.
The need for nursing home care on reservations is large and growing, the
committee was told.
At least 30 elderly residents of the Crow Creek Indian Reservation need such
care, said Wanda Wells, a tribal planner. Some older people must sell homes
and land to pay for care in off-reservation facilities as far away as Sioux
Falls, she said, and they lose contact with relatives and family.
"It really bothers me that everything is referring to the dollar amounts and
not the value of the elderly,'' she said.
Democrat Rep. Tom Van Norman of Eagle Butte said elderly members of his
tribe must go as far away as Mobridge or Pierre for nursing-home care.
"We already have a bunch of people on Cheyenne River who need this type of
care,'' he said.
The Rosebud Sioux Tribe bought an existing nursing home five years ago, off
the reservation in White River. Because the facility already was licensed,
it didn't run afoul of the moratorium. Valandra said the tribe is
subsidizing operation at a rate of nearly $100,000 a year.
Rosebud Tribal Vice Chairman Vernon Ike Schmidt said 30 of the 32 current
residents of the White River home are tribal members. Ideally, he said, the
facility should be moved to Rosebud, where the IHS hospital is located.
The Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe has designed a 40-bed nursing home that it
would like to build near Eagle Butte, Van Norman said. The tribe might be
able to finance construction, but ongoing costs would require Medicaid
funds, he said.
"If a reservation were going to go into this business, they could do that,
but they couldn't afford to stay in business without access to these
funds,'' he said. "It's ironic to me that the poorest people in the state
have the hardest time getting into nursing homes.''
© 2002 Copyright Argus Leader.
http://www.yankton.net, Saturday, September 14, 2002
By CHET BROKAW
PIERRE, S.D. (AP) -- "A South Dakota legislative panel voted unanimously
Friday to support a congressional measure that would allow nursing homes to
be built on Indian reservations.
The Legislature's State-Tribal Relations Committee decided to send a letter
to Congress endorsing a bill introduced in July by Sens. Tom Daschle and Tim
Johnson of South Dakota.
"We're laying this problem to some extent at the feet of Congress because
that's where we believe it should be solved,'' said Sen. Jim Putnam,
R-Armour, chairman of the committee.
State government cannot afford to increase spending on nursing homes, but
the federal government has an obligation under treaties and other agreements
to provide health care to Indians, Putnam said.
The problem arose in 1988, when the South Dakota Legislature approved a
moratorium that prevents construction of new nursing homes or the addition
of additional beds in existing nursing homes.
The moratorium was imposed because South Dakota had too many nursing home
beds, and that meant state spending was increasing rapidly on Medicaid, a
state-federal program that pays the bills for most people in nursing homes.
The federal government pays about two-thirds of the cost of Medicaid, and
state government pays the other one-third.
Nursing homes are needed on the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation and several
other reservations because existing facilities are located too far away.
But because of the state moratorium, any nursing home built on a reservation
would not get a state license. Without a state license, such a nursing home
would go broke because it would be unable to get Medicaid funding for its
Measures seeking to loosen the state moratorium so nursing homes could be
built on reservations have repeatedly failed in the state Legislature over
the past decade. But state lawmakers have passed resolutions asking Congress
to solve the problem.
The bill in Congress would allow construction of nursing homes on South
Dakota reservations by requiring that the federal government pay 100 percent
of the Medicaid cost for patients in tribal nursing homes.
In a letter to the state legislative committee, Daschle said the Bush
administration opposes the plan for having the federal government pay 100
percent of Medicaid costs in tribal nursing homes. He said the measure's
prospects are uncertain, but it may at least encourage further discussion
about how best to provide nursing homes on reservations.
Rep. Tom Van Norman, D-Eagle Butte, said some elderly residents of the
Cheyenne River Sioux Reservation need nursing home care, but the nearest
nursing home is in Mobridge, about 85 miles from Eagle Butte. They resist
going into nursing homes off the reservation because relatives have a hard
time traveling to see them, he said.
"It's ironic to me the poorest people in the state have the hardest time
getting into nursing homes,'' he said.
Sen. Arnold Brown, R-Brookings, urged state lawmakers to contact members of
Congress from other states to build support for the Daschle-Johnson bill.
The effort should be done for Sen. Dick Hagen, D-Pine Ridge, who is now in
poor health, Brown said. Hagen has tried for years to find a way to get
nursing homes built on reservations."
© Copyright 2002, Yankton Daily Press & Dakotan.
home : mission statement : contact : site map : search : store : links
DLN coalition : DLN issues : DLN nation : related issues
Any reprints are under the Fair Use doctrine of international copyright law : See http://www.dlncoalition.org/fair_use.htm.